Good evening đđź If you hang around theater people long enough or somehow end up on the theater side of TikTok, eventually youâll hear an age-old sentiment: Theater is dying.
So who decides? Whatâs the barometer?
Not surprisingly, I donât think itâs black and white. There are a million ways to parse through the limited public data and a million more ways to interpret it. Which is likely why thereâs no consensus on the health of The Theatre.
So while I wouldnât call buttsinseats.xyz my âsolutionâ or even my âanswer,â I might categorize it closer to an attempt at conjuring a small dose of optimism in a culture that seems to get high on pessimism.
This week, I want to break down the what, why, and how of this small, strange side quest.
Here we go.
The Why
Pessimism is easy. Headlines about theaters closing or audiences dwindling practically write themselves. But if thatâs the only story we tell, it becomes self-fulfilling.
Theater has always been measured by presence more than profit. A century ago, Broadway attendance rivaled baseball. During the Depression, ticket prices dropped but houses still filled. Even today, the NEA tracks attendance per capita as a marker of civic health.
And it isnât just symbolic. Science keeps showing us what happens when people gather. Heartbeat literally syncs with the people around us. Sociologists call it collective effervescence. What we feel is a steadiness: proof that weâre not alone.
Optimism itself works the same way. Psychologists call it the broaden-and-build effect: hope and joy expand our perspective, fuel our creativity, and strengthen our resilience. Negativity narrows, optimism widens. Without hope, we shrink. With it, we risk. We make. We show up.
Thatâs why optimism mattersânot as a mood, but as a condition of possibility. Pessimism curdles into despair. Optimism ripens into hope.
Which led me to the next question: how do you actually give people optimism in a culture hooked on pessimism?
The How
What our brains crave isnât detail. It isnât completeness. Itâs coherence.
A story simple enough to hold.
Thatâs why the phrase âtheater is dyingâ sticks. Itâs easy to say, easy to share, easy to believe. Complexity muddies the signal. Completeness overwhelms. But coherence cuts through.
And coherence isnât owned by pessimism. The same mechanism can work in service of optimism. A single numberâhow many people sat in theaters last weekâis just as coherent. Just as easy to repeat.
It may not capture every nuance, but thatâs not its job. Its job is to remind us that people are still showing up. ButtsâŚ.in seats.
Last week I wrote about how bandwagons thrive on simplicity. This is the other side of the coin. If bad news can travel fast because itâs clean and coherent, then so can good news. One number can carry just as much weight as a headline, only instead of feeding dread, it offers a spark of hope.
The What
Thatâs why I built buttsinseats.xyz.
It isnât a dashboard. It isnât a data dump. Itâs one page, one big number, updated every Monday: how many people sat in a (Broadway*) theater last week.
(I also included how many shows were running because it made me smile âşď¸)
Itâs not meant to be comprehensive. Itâs not meant to be a solution. Itâs meant to be simple. A smile.
And for me personally, it was also a small practice of hope. I built the entire site from scratch!! Iâm pretty proud!!
But this is only Broadway. What if we could tally touring houses, regional theaters, community black boxes, college and high school auditoriums?
What if there was a single figure, every week: this many people saw a show.
Not competition, not comparison. Unity. A reminder that whether itâs New York or Nebraska or Northern Ireland, weâre all working toward the same thing: more butts in seats.
Kinda fun, right?
One Last Thing
Writing about âDrama at the Drama Schoolâ a few weeks ago got me thinking about being a theater kid in high school. I made a list. Made a video reading the list. It was half joke, half nostalgia. I didnât think much of it.
Well. My comments exploded with hilarious anecdotes from fellow thespians. The Couch đ
And that in itself felt clarifying. I am in a constant sea of questions. My Instagram handle is @whoismattrodin. I love pulling things apart, dissecting the complexity. I love using a prism of history and science and philosophy to understand concepts more deeply. Thatâs reeeeally fun for me. But as weâve seen, sometimes simple labels cut through in a way that complexity canât.
Theater kid. It was funny, but itâs also true. Because, as cheesy as it sounds, a theater has always been a home for me. Watching, working. Just being in the building.
And I know Iâm not alone in that. A lot of you reading this were (or still are) theater kids, or at least carry that piece of yourself somewhere close. Thatâs part of why I built Butts in Seats: because as long as there are butts in seats, there will be theater kids.
Long live us.
See you next week âĽď¸
âMatt



